Magic Of The Musicals
Louise Gold starred on Disc Two – The Best Of West End as Reno Sweeney from Anything Goes and featured on Disc Three – The Best Of Broadway as Maria a Kit Kat Klub girl from Cabaret.
Catalogue number: DECTV015
STOP PRESS: Louise Gold has
two nominations in the Broadway World West End Awards: http://www.broadwayworld.com/westend/vote2015region.cfm
In particular she has been
nominated for Understudy of The Year Female: http://www.broadwayworld.com/westend/liveupdate2015region.cfm?btype=4338®ion=UK%20/%20West%20End#sthash.2TIlL8gx.dpbs (for her performance as Momma
Rose – she understudied Imelda Staunton)
Cast
Irfan Ahmed (as The Artful Dodger from Oliver!)
Thomas Allen (as Fred Graham from Kiss Me Kate)
Rosemary Ashe (as Hortense from The Boyfriend)
John Barrowman (as
Josephine Barstow
(as
Gillian Bevan (as Dorothy Gale from The Wizard Of Oz)
Graham Bickley (as Chris from Miss Saigon, and, Gaston Lachailles from Gigi)
Matt Bogart
Bonaventura Bottone ( as Detlof from The Student Prince)
Simon Bowman (as Caractacus Potts from Chitty Chitty Bang Bang)
Clare Burt (as Frenchie a Kit Kat Klub girl from Cabaret – uncredited, and, Rizzo from Grease)
Danielle Carson (as Linda from Pal Joey)
Carol Channing (as Dolly Levi from Hello Dolly)
Dean Collinson
Kim Criswell (as Grizelbella from Cats, Norma Desmond from Sunset Boulevard, Kim from Miss Saigon, Mary Magdelene from Jesus Christ Superstar, and, Eva Peron from Evita)
Jacqueline Dankworth (as Fritzi a Kit Kat Klub girl from Cabaret – uncredited)
Muriel Dickinson
Tim Flavin (as Brad Majors from The Rocky Horror Show)
Julian Forsyth (as Fagin from Oliver!)
Hal Fowler (as Adam Pontipee from Seven Brides For Seven Brothers)
Louise Gold (as Reno Sweeney from Anything Goes, and, Maria a Kit Kat Klub girl from Cabaret - uncredited)
James Graeme (as Bert from Mary Poppins, and others)
Debbie Gravitte (as Annie Oakley from Annie Get Your Gun, and, Calamity Jane from Calamity Jane)
Andrew Halliday (as The Phantom from The Phantom Of The Opera, and others)
Lindsay Hamilton (as Gigi from Gigi)
Richard Harris (as King Arthur from Camelot)
James Head (as Tom Jenkins from Scrooge)
Jan Hovath (as
Velma Kelly from
Vanessa A Jones
Megan Kelly (as Bet from Oliver!)
Doug LaBrecque
Jerry Lanning (as Tervye from Fiddler On The Roof)
Denis Lawson (as Joey from Pal Joey)
Shona Lindsay (as Sandy from Grease, and, Maria from The Sound Of Music)
Valerie Masterson (as Marsinah from Kismet, and, Anna Leonowens from The King And I)
Sean McDermott
J. Mark McVey (as
Tony from
William Michals (as Emil De Becque from South Pacific)
Max Milner (as Jeremy Potts from Chitty Chitty Bang Bang)
Diana Montague (as Lilli Vanessi from Kiss Me Kate)
Ron Moody (as Alfred P Doolittle from My Fair Lady)
Claire Moore (as Rosie a Kit Kat Klub girl from Cabaret – uncredited)
Katrina Murphy (as Christine from The Phantom Of The Opera, and others)
Deborah Myers (as Desiree from A Little Night Music, Mary Poppins from Mary Poppins)
Caroline O’Connor
(as Donna Sheridan from Mamma
Jonathan Pryce (as The MC from Cabaret)
Ron Raines (as Sky Masterson from Guys And Dolls)
David Rendell (as Prince Karl Franz from The Student Prince, and, The Caliph from Kismet, and others)
Grania Renihan
Howard Samuels (as Frank ‘n’ Furter from The Rocky Horror Show)
Jacqui Scott
David Shannon
Gay Soper (as Lulu a Kit Kat Klub girl from Cabaret - uncredited
Richard South (as Oliver Twist from Oliver!)
Sally Ann Triplett (as Truly Scrumptious from Chitty Chitty Bang Bang, and others)
Richard Van Allan (as Joe from Showboat)
Sal Viviano (as
Curly from
Hayley Wareham (as Jemima Potts from Chitty Chitty Bang Bang)
Elisabeth Welch
Jacinta Whyte
Production Team
Conductors – Gerry Allison, Craig Barna, Jonathan Cohen, Janet Glazner, Julian Kelly, John Owen Edwards, Stuart Pedlar, Patrick Vaccariello, Chris Walker, Martin Yates, and, Trevor York
Orchestra – The company orchestra from The Boyfriend, The Estonian National Symphony Orchestra, The National Symphony Orchestra/NSO/NSO Ensemble, The Philharmonia Orchestra
Produced by John Yap from JAY Productions, for Decadence Recordings
Project Managed by Duncan Collins
Track Listing
Disc One – The Best
Of Today
1. All That Jazz (from
2. Dancing Queen (from Mamma Mia!) – Caroline O’Connor with the NSO Ensemble conducted by Julian Kelly
3. Shakalaka Baby (from Bombay Dreams) – Jacinta Whyte, and, David Shannon with the National Symphony Orchestra conducted
by Martin Yates
4. The Circle Of
Life (from The
Lion King) –
5. Only You (from Starlight Express) – Grania Renihan with the NSO Ensemble conducted by John Owen Edwards
6. Summer Nights (from Grease) – John Barrowman, Shona Lindsay, and company with the NSO Ensemble conducted by Martin
Yates
7. Chitty Chitty
Bang Bang (from Chitty
Chitty Bang Bang) – Simon Bowman,
Sally Ann Triplett, Max Milner, and, Hayley Wareham with the National
Symphony Orchestra conducted by Martin
Yates
8. You Walk With Me (from The Fully Monty) – Sean McDermott, and, Matt Bogart with the NSO Ensemble conducted by Craig Barna
9. We Are The
Champions (from We
Will Rock You) – Dean Collinson,
James Graeme,
10. What Kind Of
Fool (from Saturday
Night Fever) – Caroline O’Connor
with the NSO Ensemble conducted by Julian Kelly
11. Elaborate Lives (from Aida) – Sean McDermott, and, Vanessa A Jones with the NSO Ensemble conducted by Patrick Vaccariello
12. Our Kind Of Love (from The Beautiful Game) – Sally Ann Triplett with the National Symphony Orchestra conducted
by Martin Yates
13. Whistle Down The
Wind (from Whistle
Down The Wind) – James Graeme
and the NSO Ensemble conducted by Martin Yates
14. Ruby Baby (from Smokey Joe’s Cafe) – Matt Bogart and boys with the NSO Ensemble conducted by Patrick Vaccariello
15. If I Can’t Love
Her (from Beauty
And The Beast) – James Graeme
with the National Symphony Orchestra
conducted by Martin Yates
Disc 2 – The Best Of
The
1. All I Ask Of You (from The Phantom Of The Opera)
– Andrew Halliday, and, Katrina Murphy with the National Symphony Orchestra conducted
by Martin Yates
2. Memory (from Cats) – Kim Criswell with the National Symphony Orchestra conducted
by Martin Yates
3. Any Dream Will Do (from Joseph And The Amazing
Technicolor Dreamcoat) – John
Barrowman with the NSO Ensemble
conducted by John Owen Edwards
4. I’d Do Anything (from Oliver!) – Irfan Ahmed, Josephine Barstow, Richard
South, Megan Kelly, Julian Forsyth and boys with the National Symphony Orchestra conducted
by John Owen Edwards
5. Anything Goes (from Anything Goes) – Louise Gold and company with the National Symphony Orchestra conducted
by John Owen Edwards
6. I Know Him So
Well (from Chess)
– Sally Ann Triplett, and, Katrina Murphy with the NSO Ensemble conducted by Martin Yates
7. With One Look (from Sunset Boulevard) – Kim Criswell with the National Symphony Orchestra conducted
by Martin Yates
8. The People’s Song (from Les Miserables) – the
Company from the JAY/TER cast
recording with the National Symphony
Orchestra conducted by Martin Yates
9. The Last Night Of
The World (from Miss
Saigon) – Graham Bickley,
and, Kim Criswell with the National Symphony Orchestra conducted
by Martin Yates
10. Thoroughly
Modern Millie
(from Thoroughly Modern Mille) – Jacqui
Scott with the National Symphony
Orchestra conducted by Martin Yates
11. I Don’t Know How
To Love Him
(from
Jesus Christ Superstar) – Kim
Criswell with the National Symphony
Orchestra conducted by John Owen
Edwards
12. It’s Nicer In
Nice (from The
Boyfriend) – Rosemary Ashe
and company orchestra conducted by Chris Walker
13. One Song Glory (from Rent) – Sean McDermott with the NSO Ensemble conducted by Martin Yates
14. Rainbow High (from Evita) – Kim Criswell and men with the National Symphony Orchestra conducted
by Martin Yates
15. Sweet
Transvestite
(from The Rocky Horror Show) – Howard
Samuels, and, Tim Flavin with
the NSO Ensemble conducted by Martin Yates
Disc 3 – The Best Of
Broadway
1. Do Re Mi (from The Sound Of Music) – Shona Lindsay and Children with the National Symphony Orchestra conducted
by John Owen Edwards
2. Willkommen (from Cabaret) – Jonathan Pryce and company (including: Louise Gold, Gay Soper, Claire Moore,
Jacqueline Dankworth, Caroline O’Connor, and, Clare Burt) with the National Symphony Orchestra conducted
by John Owen Edwards
3. Oh, What A Beautiful
Morning (from
4. Maria (from West Side Story) – J. Mark McVey with the National Symphony Orchestra conducted
by John Owen Edwards
5. If I Were A Rich
Man (from Fiddler
On The Roof) – Jerry Lanning
with the National Symphony Orchestra
conducted by John Owen Edwards
6. Luck Be A Lady (from Guys And Dolls) – Ron Raines with the National Symphony Orchestra conducted
by Martin Yates
7. You’ll Never Walk
Alone (from Carousel)
– Muriel Dickinson with the National Symphony Orchestra conducted
by John Owen Edwards
8. Stranger In
9. Get Me To The
Church On Time
(from My Fair Lady) – Ron
Moody and company with the National
Symphony Orchestra conducted by John
Owen Edwards
10. Send In The
Clowns (from A
Little Night Music) – Deborah
Myers with the National Symphony
Orchestra conducted by Martin Yates
11. Some Enchanted
Evening (from South
Pacific) – William Michals
with the National Symphony Orchestra
conducted by John Owen Edwards
12.
13. Hello Young
Lovers (from The
King And I) – Valerie Masterson
with The Philharmonia Orchestra
conducted by John Owen Edwards
14. Wunderbar (from Kiss Me Kate) – Thomas Allen, and, Diana Montague with the National
Symphony Orchestra conducted by John
Owen Edwards
15. There’s No
Business Like Showbusiness
(from Annie Get Your Gun) -
Disc 4 – The Best Of
1. Singin’ In The
Rain (from Singin’
In The Rain) –
2. Over The Rainbow (from The Wizard Of Oz) – Gillian Bevan with orchestra conducted
by John Owen Edwards
3. There Are Worse
Things I Could Do
(from Grease) – Clare Burt
with the NSO Ensemble conducted by Martin Yates
4.
Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious (from Mary Poppins) – Deborah Myers, and, James
Graeme with the National Symphony
Orchestra conducted by Martin Yates
5. Dames (from
6. Bless Your
Beautiful Hide
(from Seven Brides For Seven Brothers) – Hal Fowler with the National
Symphony Orchestra conducted by Martin
Yates
7. The Night They
Invented
8. Big Spender (from Sweet Charity) – Caroline O’Connor and girls with the National Symphony Orchestra conducted
by Martin Yates
9. Before The Parade
Passes By (from Hello
Dolly) – Carol Channing with
orchestra conducted by Janet Glazner
10. Drinking Song (from The Student Prince) – David Rendall, Bonaventura Bottone and company with the Philharmonia Orchestra conducted by John Owen Edwards
11. How To Handle A
Woman (from Camelot)
– Richard Harris with orchestra
conducted by Gerry Allison
12. Secret Love (from Calamity Jane) – Debbie Gravitte with the National Symphony Orchestra conducted
by John Owen Edwards
13. I Could Write A
Book (from Pal
Joey) – Denis Lawson, and, Danielle Carson with an orchestra
conducted by Trevor York
14. True Love (from High Society) – Elisabeth Welch with orchestra conducted
by Jonathan Cohen
15. Thank You Very
Much (from Scrooge)-
James Head and company with
orchestra conducted by Stuart Pedlar
The
Sleeve notes give the song Summer Nights from the musical Grease
as having music and lyrics by John
Barrowman, this is of course a mistake, the music and lyrics are actually
by Jim Jacobs and Warren Casey, while John Barrowman simply happens to be
singing the role of
The
Sleeve Notes give David Randall as
appearing in the Student Prince, that entry should have been the tenor David Rendall.
The
Sleeve Notes give Gerry Anderson as
conducting How To Handle A Woman, that entry should have been the
conductor Gerry Allison.
Jonathan Pryce (along with: Clare Burt, Jacqueline
Dankworth, Louise Gold, Claire Moore, Caroline O’Connor, and, Gay
Soper)’s performance of Wilkommen comes from the JAY/TER recording of Cabaret, on which Megan
Kelly, and, Howard
Louise Gold and company’s performance of Anything
Goes comes from the JAY/TER
recording Anything Goes (Recording) –
Website Recommended Album,
on which Katrina Murphy can also be
heard, and which also features the National
Symphony Orchestra conducted by John
Owen Edwards. In addition Louise
Gold also sang that song when she appeared in a
Irfan Ahamed, John
Barrowman, Clare Burt, Jacqueline Dankworth, Richard Harris, Shona Lindsay, Valerie
Masterson, Claire Moore, Caroline O’Connor, Jonathan Pryce, Gay Soper,
and, Richard South can also be heard
on Centre Stage Showtime!, which also
features the National Symphony Orchestra
conducted by Gerry Allison, John Owen Edwards, and, Martin Yates. That album contains the
same recordings of: Summer Nights, Willkommen, Over The Rainbow, and, How
To Handle A Woman.
Thomas Allen, Graham
Bickley, Carol Channing,
Thomas Allen, Graham
Bickley, Clare Burt, Kim Criswell, Tim Flavin, Hal Fowler, James Graeme,
Thomas Allen, Graham
Bickley, Valerie Masterson, Ron Moody, Katrina Murphy, Sian
Phillips, and, David Rendell can
also be heard on Great Duets From
The Musicals, which also features the National
Symphony Orchestra, and, the Philharmonia
Orchestra conducted by John Owen
Edwards, and, Martin Yates. That
album contains the same recordings of Stranger In Paradise.
Thomas Allen, Graham
Bickley, Clare Burt, Diana Montague, Katrina Murphy, and, Elisabeth
Welch can also be heard on Cole
Porter – Night And Day, which also features the National Symphony Orchestra conducted by Jonathan Cohen, John Owen
Edwards, Chris Walker, and, Martin Yates. That album also contains
the same recordings of: Anything Goes,
and, Wunderbar.
Thomas Allen, John
Barrowman, Kim Criswell, Tim Flavin, Julian Forsyth,
Thomas Allen appeared on television on The Ghost Of
Faffner Hall.
Thomas Allen, Graham
Bickley, Matt Bogart, Kim Criswell,
Thomas Allen, Graham
Bickley, Danielle Carson, Lindsay Hamilton, Doug LaBreque, Caroline
O’Connor, Ron Raines, and, Elisabeth Welch can also be heard on The Great Musicals – Dashing Heroes,
Blushing Maidens, which also features the National Symphony Orchestra conducted by Gerry Allison, Julian Kelly,
John Owen Edwards, and, Martin Yates.
Rosemary Ashe, and, Sally Ann
Triplett appeared in The Metropolitan
Mikado, where the orchestra was conducted by John Owen Edwards.
Rosemary Ashe, and, Gay Soper
appeared in a concert of Highlights from the
Ratepayers’ Iolanthe & Metropolitan Mikado, for which the orchestra was
conducted by John Owen Edwards.
Rosemary Ashe, and, Gay Soper
appeared in The Soap Opera, which was written
by Martin Yates.
John Barrowman has appeared on stage in the musical Anything Goes (Stage production) in two
productions (one with Louise Gold
and one with Sally-Ann Triplett as
John Barrowman, and, James Graeme
appeared in Chicago & Company, on
which Stuart Pedlar also worked.
John Barrowman, Graham
Bickley, Simon Bowman, Clare Burt, Dean Collinson, Kim Criswell,
Muriel Dickinson, James Graeme, Debbie Gravitte,
Gillian Bevan, and, Claire Moore
may have appeared in Comedy Tonight.
Gillian Bevan, and, Claire Moore
appeared in Kids At Heart, which Elisabeth Welch may have appeared in,
and on which Stuart Pedlar also
worked.
Gillian Bevan appeared in Blood
Brothers, and, The Boys From Syracuse.
Gillian Bevan, and, Gay Soper
appeared in the Regent’s Park 70th
Anniversary Gala.
Graham Bickley appeared in The Pirates Of
Penzance (Stage Production), The Pirates Of
Penzance (Gala Performance), The Pirates Of Penzance
(Royal Gala Preview), and, The Pirates Of Penzance
(Benefit Preview). He has since appeared in Mexican
Hayride.
Graham Bickley, and, Richard Harris
appeared in The Royal Variety
Performance (1982).
Graham Bickley, Kim
Criswell, James Graeme, Richard Harris, Valerie Masterson, Ron Moody,
Deborah Myers, Caroline O’Connor, and, Jonathan
Pryce can also be heard on The Great Musicals
– Wonderful Tales, which also features the National Symphony Orchestra, and, the Philharmonia Orchestra conducted by Gerry Allison, Julian Kelly,
John Owen Edwards, and. Martin Yates. That album contains the
same recordings of Anything Goes.
Clare Burt, Kim
Criswell, Richard Harris,
Clare Burt, Denis
Lawson, Gay Soper, and, Sally Ann Triplett appeared in A Love Letter To Dan.
Clare Burt, Kim
Criswell, Jacqueline Dankworth, James Graeme, Doug LaBreque, Valerie
Masterson, and, Ron Raines can
also be heard on The Great Musicals – Laughter
And Tears, which also features the National
Symphony Orchestra conducted by Craig
Barna, John Owen Edwards, Chris Walker, and, Martin Yates. That album contains the same recording of There
Are Worse Things I Could Do.
Danielle Carson appeared in By
Jupiter, Du Barry Was A Lady (1993 Production), and, Red Hot And Blue.
Danielle Carson, Lindsay
Hamilton, and, Katrina Murphy
can also be heard on Stop The
World I Want To Get Off, which also features the National Symphony Orchestra conducted by Martin Yates.
Carol Channing was a Guest Star on The Muppet Show.
Kim Criswell appeared in Gentlemen Prefer Blondes, and on the
radio in Let ‘Em Eat Cake.
Kim Criswell, Tim
Flavin, Valerie Masterson, and, Katrina Murphy can also be heard on On The Town, which also featured the National Symphony Orchestra conducted
by John Owen Edwards.
Jacqueline Dankworth appeared in Merrily We Roll Along (Stage Production)
and can be heard on the associated album Merrily We Roll Along (Recording),
both of which were conducted by Julian
Kelly.
Tim Flavin, James
Graeme, and,
Tim Flavin, and, Jonathan Pryce
appeared on television in A Week In The
West End.
Hal Fowler, and, James Head
appeared in Calamity Jane, which was conducted
by Julian Kelly.
Claire Moore, and, Elisabeth
Welch appeared in A Time To Start
Living, which James Graeme may
have taken part in.
Claire Moore may have appeared in Will Aid, which
Jonathan Cohen may have conducted on.
Grania Renihan, and, Gay Soper
appeared at Dress Circle Grand
Reopening.
Howard
Gay Soper, and, Sally Ann
Triplett appeared in the Side By Side By
Sondheim 30th Anniversary Gala.
Sally Ann Triplett appeared in Happily Ever After, and, on television in Rita Rudner.
Sally Ann Triplett appeared in the Side By Side By Sondheim 25th
Anniversary Gala, for which Stuart
Pedlar was a pianist.
Julian Kelly conducted Follies.
Chris Walker did orchestrations for Chitty Chitty Bang Bang.
John Barrowman, Simon
Bowman, Dean Collinson, Kim Criswell, Louise Gold, James Graeme,
Andrew Halliday, Richard Harris,
Clare Burt, Jacqueline
Dankworth, Jonathan Cohen, Claire Moore, Grainne Renihan, Trevor York,
Gillian Bevan, and, Sally Ann Triplett may have taken part
in Thing A Thon.
Sian Phillips, and, Gay Soper
went on to take part in Shopping
With The Stars 2009.
John Barrowman, Gillian
Bevan, Matt Bogart, Simon Bowman, Danielle Carson, Kim
Criswell, Jacqueline Dankworth, Louise Gold, James Graeme, Debbie
Gravitte, Andrew Halliday,
Thomas Allen, Boneventura
Bottone, Clare Burt, Jacqueline Dankworth, Muriel Dickinson, Louise Gold, Richard Harris,
Valerie Masterson, Diana Montague, Claire Moore, Caroline
O’Connor, Sian Phillips, Jonathan Pryce, David Rendall, and, Gay
Soper can also be heard on Let’s Go
On With The Show – Hit Songs From The West End & Broadway; accompanied
by The National Symphony Orchestra,
with maestros Gerry Allison, Janet Glazener, and, John Owen Edwards. This album includes
the same recordings of Wilkommen, Wunderbar, You’ll
Never Walk Alone, Stranger In Paradise, and, The
Drinking Song.
Irfan Ahmad, Gillian
Bevan, Graham Bickley, Clare Burt, Kim Criswell, Jacqueline
Dankworth, Julian Forsyth, Doug LaBrecque, Claire Moore, Katrina Murphy,
Caroline O’Connor,
Review
by
Yet another compilation album from the JAY/TER catalogue, even if this time it is on the Decadence label. At first glance much of it seems to be material already present on other JAY/TER compilations, particularly Simply Musicals. Nevertheless on closer inspection the album does turn up a few surprising gems.
As with any compilation album of this nature it is a very mixed bunch of songs, some of which any given listener will like and some one won’t. That doesn’t necessarily mean they are bad songs or bad performances, just that we don’t all have the same taste.
Overall I was not much taken with Disc
1 – The Best Of Today, but then I’m not so keen on many of “today’s”
musicals, with their strong pop focus. Nevertheless the first half of the disc
was performed with a good deal of verve; and contained may numbers one would
want to sing a long too; in particular Jan
Hovath’s All That Jazz, John
Barrowman and Shona Lindsay’s Summer
Nights, and most especially Simon
Bowman, Sally Ann Triplett, Max Milner and Hayley Wareham’s Chitty Chitty Bang Bang. Meanwhile Jacinta Whyte and David Shannon performed Shakalaka Baby well, although I
don’t like the song, and likewise Andrew
Halliday and
Among the four discs my favourite was Disc 2 – The Best Of The West End, possibly largely because of the strong presence of Kim Criswell, along with one splendid performance from Louise Gold. As with the whole album even this disc was a mixed bunch. Kim Criswell’s performances were generally among the best, it being particularly splendid to have her famous ‘haunting’ rendition of Memory, along with her expert rendition of With One Look (which is one of my favourite Andrew Lloyd-Webber songs – and I’m not that keen Lloyd-Webber’s work). She also does a good job with I Don’t Know How To Love Him, although in my opinion that isn’t as great a song. While her Rainbow High is a surprise, I don’t think the song in general and her recording of it in particular finds it’s way onto compilation albums that much, in fact although I had heard the song on her Back To Before solo album I had totally forgotten all about it, so hearing it here was like hearing it anew, quite a treat. Not perhaps one of her greatest performances (and yes I think there might be singers who could make this even more their own), but nevertheless nice to hear her do something fresh. I was rather less keen on the extract of Kim’s performance from Miss Saigon, but that’s probably just because I don’t really like Bournbille ad Schoneberg. That said this disc does happen to feature the one song of theirs that I do like, The People’s Song, which is given a typically rousing performance. Another rousing performance, and a song I hadn’t heard before is the title song from Thoroughly Modern Millie, which I was delighted to hear. As for It’s Nicer In Nice, another new one to me, well it’s a nice song, but I would’ve preferred to hear it sung in a more straightforward manner. I felt that Rosemary Ashe’s performance was too over-the-top. I’d like to hear someone like Belinda Lang attempt this (not a great singer, but with a good arranger I think she might be able to do it decently). I think this song could do with a bit more simplicity and less messing around with accents. Another song which I felt would have benefited from different singers is I Know Him So Well. Sally Ann Triplett is a fairly accomplished performer, but she has her limitations. There are some songs which she can interpret brilliantly, but I’ve also come across a number of instances where her talents are stretched, perhaps a little too far. Listening to this song, I couldn’t help wondering what a singer such as Louise Plowright would be like were she ever to sing this. Worth a try, perhaps? (especially given her experience with the musical Mamma Mia!). And then there’s All I Ask Of You, Andrew Halliday and Katrina Murphy sing it reasonably well, although I can’t help thinking that Andrew Halliday came across rather better on the CD of George Posford & Eric Maschwitz’s Zip Goes A Million (when he teamed up with Louise Davidson). This disc also includes a surprisingly decent performance of the Lionel Bart classic I’d Do Anything. The only time I’ve heard a performance from Josephine Barstow that I actually thought not bad. While it’s a pleasure to have, even briefly, the excellent Julian Forsyth. This rousing classic of Bart’s is followed, perhaps appropriately, by a terrific performance, that of Louise Gold belting Cole Porter’s Anything Goes. Where, even down to intonation on any given note, she manages to sound uncannily like a certain Muppet-Girl-Monster, on Sesame Street. If you’ve ever had the pleasure of hearing the marvellous Monsterpiece Theatre sketch Anyone’s Nose you will recognise the similarity instantly. Pure brilliance.
While I liked the songs on Disc 3 – The Best Of Broadway,
most of the performances were while perfectly pleasant, I have heard better in
most cases. The exceptions to this were: Jonathan
Pyrce (and a bunch of uncredited
I was pleasantly surprised by the standard of the
performances on Disc 4 – The Best Of Hollywood, where a bunch of contemporary,
singers stood up vocally surprisingly well to some legendary film stars.
Overall as very mixed set of discs. The sort of thing that mostly makes pretty good background music, and might be quite good for playing on a long car journey, or in the background at a party. Not necessarily that worth buying for the individual performances, as most of these can be obtained elsewhere, on albums relating to specific shows or performers. Nevertheless some of the performances are certainly eye-openers, either to shows one might not have thought of listening to, or sometimes different sides to talents of performers one thought one knew about. An interesting album yes, not necessarily a must have, one could do without it, but, like so many compilation albums one might consider it as a possibly useful acquisition. Oh yes, and if you are a fan of Kim Criswell’s then this is definitely worth considering (although if you are that much of a fan you may well already have all the tracks she sings on it on other albums).
Critics Comments
.
Links about Magic Of The Musicals